INSIGHTS: THE INTERPRETATION OF ISLAM WITHIN THE FRAMEWORK OF THE INDIGENOUS MALAYA
Abstract
This article promotes Islam's interpretation within the legal framework of the indigenous Malayan based on its principle of sovereignty. At present, Islam is popularly defined by the Court's decision in Che Omar Che Soh vs Public Prosecutor, where the sovereignty of the Malay Rulers was made as a parameter in interpreting Islam within the context of Article 3 of the Federal Constitution. The said decision confines Islam only in the context of personal laws due to the Pangkor Treaty, 1874. This is a qualitative study applying the legal history design. The findings showed that the indigenous sovereignty sourced from the Islamic teachings had not been affected despite the introduction of doctrine of advice and various British policies throughout their intervention in Malaya. In fact, many agreements made between the Malay Rulers and the British retained the indigenous sovereignty as those agreements were subjected to the old Malayan Constitution, the principle of Islam as the law of the land as well as the contemporary local thinking. The above three local circumstances explained the principle of sovereignty, thus the position of Islam in the indigenous Malaya's legal framework. This article concludes that the accurate interpretation of Islam should be based on the al-Qur'an and al-Sunnah because the Malay Rulers have retained their position as a caliph even after the British intervened in their internal state affairs.
References
Ahmad Ibrahim. Common law in Malaysia (1989) 1(1) KANUN 3-25
Allen, J. de, A. J. Stockwell and L. R. Wright (eds.) 1981. A Collection of Treaties and Other Documents Affecting the States of Malaysia. Vol. 2 London: Oceana Publications.
Andaya, Barbara W. & Leonard Y. Andaya. 1984. A History of Malaysia. Hong Kong: Macmillan Press.
Arieff Salleh Rosman & Yahaya Jusoh. 2015. Tafsir Maudhu’iy; Politik dan Urus Tadbir. Kuala Lumpur: Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka.
Curzon, L.B. 2007. Dictionary of Law. Ed. ke-6. Kuala Lumpur: International Law Book Services.
Harding, Andrew. 1996. Law, Government and the Constitution in Malaysia. Kuala Lumpur: Malayan Law Journal Sdn. Bhd.
Hashim Yeop A. Sani, Datuk 1980. Perlembagaan Kita. Kuala Lumpur: Malaysian Law Publisher.
Liaw Yock Fang (Ketua Editor Hassan Ahmad). 2003. Karya Agung: Undang-Undang Melaka. Kuala Lumpur: Yayasan Karyawan.
Lina Joy vs The Federal Territory Islamic Religious Council & et.al. JH (1428), Vol. 24 Sect. 1)
Lopez, Carolina. 2001. The British Presence in the Malay World: A Meeting of Civilisational Traditions. Sari 19 (2001): 3-33.
MB Hooker, Islamic Law in South-east Asia, 1984.
Meor Atiqurrahman Ishak & Ors vs Fatimah Sihi & et.al. [2006] 4MLJ 605
Mohamed Anwar Omardin, Wan Ahmad Fauzi Wan Husain, Mat Zin Mat Kib & Junaidi Abu Bakar. Peranan UMNO Menegakkan Islam Dalam Perlembagaan Persekutuan: Satu Kajian Secara Kronologikal. Akademika Vol 87, No 1 (2017).
Mohammed al-Baianonie, Imam. In his Friday speech at Islamic Centre of Raleigh, North California on December, 27, 1996. www.Islam1.org/khutub/defn
Mohd Salleh Abas, Tan Sri Dato' Haji. 1984. Selected Article & Speeches on Constitution, Law & Judiciary. Kuala Lumpur: Malaysia Law Publisher Sdn. Bhd.
Muhammad Yusof Hashim. 1992. The Malay Sultanate of Malacca. Kuala Lumpur: Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka.
Philpott, D. Sovereignty. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. https://plato.stanford. edu/entries/sovereignty.
Ramah vs Laton [1927] 6FMSLR 128
Re Yap Kwan Seng's Will [1924] 4FMSLR 313
Ridzuan Awang. 1994. Undang-Undang Tanah Islam; Pendekatan Perbandingan. Selangor: Percetakan Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka.
S Abul A'ala Maududi, The Islamic Law and Consttution, March 1980, (7th. Edition).
Stockwell, A. J. 1979. British Policy and Malay Politics during the Malayan Union Experiment, 1942–1948. Kuala Lumpur: Malaysian Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society.
W.G. Shellaber. 1977 (Edisi Ketiga). Sejarah Melayu. Selangor: Penerbit Fajar Bakti Sdn. Bhd.
Wan Ahmad Fauzi bin Wan Husain, YB Datuk. 2013. Rekonfigurasi Epistimologi Jati Diri Melayu: Manifestasinya Ke Atas Silat Seni Gayong. Latihan Ilmiah Sarjana Falsafah Jabatan Sains Sosial Dan Kemasyarakatan sesi 2012/13. Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia.
Wan Ahmad Fauzi Wan Husain. 2017. Konsep Kedaulatan Watan Raja-Raja Melayu Dalam Perlembagaan Persekutuan Malaysia Menurut Sejarah Perundangan. Tesis Ph.D, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Bangi.
Wan Ahmad Fauzi Wan Husain. 2018. Kedaulatan Raja-Raja Melayu: Jurisprudens, Governan & Prinsip Perlembagaan Persekutuan. Selangor: Abad Sinergi Sdn. Bhd.
Wan Ahmad Fauzi Wan Husain. 2020. The Conceptual Framework for Building The World Class Good Governance Ethics. Journal of Governance and Integrity, UMP. Vol. 4 Issue 2, December 2020.
Yusuf al-Qardhawi. 2009. Fiqh Kenegaraan. Kuala Lumpur: Blue-T Publication Sdn. Bhd.
NOTES
i. Indeed it was described and mentioned and indefinitely established that this Terengganu Government was the Islamiyyah Melayuwiyyah Government which was said to be the religion of the State and the Government, so no other religion could at all be made or called the religion of the State even though there were other races and religions allowed to remain peacefully in the State and territory of Terengganu.
ii. The Malay States of Pahang, Perak, Kedah and Kelantan adopted the written laws developed from the Malacca Code in line with the reinforcement of Islamic laws until introducing the British laws in the court when the British advisory system was enforced.
iii. For example, Clause 5 of the State Constitution of Negeri Sembilan (Part One) 1959 provided; "This State Religion is Islam as embraced and practised in this state: but other religions can be practised peacefully anywhere in the country by those who embraced them."
iv. As enshrined in each of the State Constitution, as a requirement (1) Clause 4 of the Terengganu State Government Laws(Part One):
The Religious Leader of this State is His Royal Highness and The Council of Islamic Religion and Malay Customs, which in the English language is called the "Council of Religion and Malay Customs" instituted under the existing State Laws and shall continue to assist and advise His Royal Highness according to those laws.
v. Salleh Abas LP stated:
Before the British came to Malaya, which was then known as Malaya, the sultans in each of their respective states were the heads not only of the religion of Islam but also the political leaders in their states, which themselves Muslims, their subjects were also Muslims, and the law applicable in the states was Muslim law. Under such, the sultan was regarded as God's vicegerent (representative) on earth. He was entrusted with the power to run the country in accordance with the law ordained by Islam, i.e. Islamic law and to see that the law was enforced.
vi. The Colonial Secretary to Residents, 17 May 1878, "The Residents have been placed in the native states as advisers, not as rulers. If they upon themselves to disregard this principle, they will most assuredly be held responsible if trouble springs out of their neglect of it."
The Author as the undersigned individual(s), shall retain copyright to the Contribution as the rightful Author(s) and the Author(s) hereby grant UMP Publisher, as the exclusive publisher of the Contribution, with the rights, conditions and terms as detailed in this Form.
Both parties acknowledge that this mutual understanding and agreement may not be able to contemplate all possible licensing arrangements, technologies or future developments, and therefore both parties agree to cooperate in good faith to achieve the mutual goals of maximizing the dissemination of the Author’s Contribution while ensuring the sustainability of scholarly publishing.
The parties hereby agree on the following terms and conditions of the publication;
- Copyright License
The Author(s) grants to UMP Publisher, a worldwide, royalty-free and exclusive license to:
- reproduce, publicly display, publicly perform and distribute the Contribution in the Publication;
- authorize third party users of the Publication in electronic or digital (or other intangible) form to download and print out copies of the Contribution for their personal or internal institutional use;
- authorize others to reproduce, publicly display, publicly perform and distribute the Contribution as part of the Publication through any distribution channels and in any media or format through which UMP Publisher may distribute or make available substantially all the contents of the Publication; and
- deposit with or otherwise make the Contribution available to digital repositories as required by the Author’s funding sources upon the Author’s request.
The above rights may be exercised in all media and formats, whether now known or hereafter devised, [and in all languages] in which the Publication as a whole (or substantially all its contents) may be distributed, whether or not the Contribution may be individually or partially accessed or retrieved. The above rights include the right to edit [and translate] the Contribution and to make such modifications as are technically necessary or desirable to exercise these rights in differing media and formats.
- Exclusive rights
The Author(s) grants to UMP Publisher the worldwide, royalty-free, exclusive right to first publish the Contribution and the Author(s) agrees not to publish or authorize any third party to publish the Contribution in any [language,] media or format, for a period ending [six (6) months] after the date of first publication of the Contribution in the Publication (“Exclusivity Period”), except as mutually agreed between the parties at later stage.
The Author(s) retains the rights at any time during the Exclusivity Period:
- reproduce and distribute a reasonable number of copies of any version of the Contribution, including but not limited to the published version, or portions or derivative works thereof, in the course of the teaching, research, conference presentations and similar professional, scientific, or academic activities (but not permission on the commercial publication or widespread distribution of the Contribution or any significant portion or derivative work thereof);
- post or otherwise make any version of the Contribution, or portions or derivative works thereof, available on the Author(s) personal web site; and
- make any version of the Contribution available on digital repositories; provided in each case UMP Publisher (and Publication) is cited as the first/forthcoming publisher of the Contribution and the Author(s) accurately distinguish any modified version of the Contribution from that published or to be published by UMP Publisher.
- Editing
UMP Publisher shall make no material modification to the content of the Contribution without the Author’s consent. However, in the event the Author(s) fails to return the edited manuscript or proofs of the Contribution by the reasonable deadline set by UMP Publisher, the Author(s) will be deemed to have consented to that modified version.
- Credit
UMP Publisher agrees to make commercially reasonable efforts to include (and require its sub-licensees to include) appropriate credit to the author(s) in customary placement with every copy or use of the Contribution as described in Sections 1 and 2 hereof.
- Complimentary copies
UMP Publisher will provide the Author(s) with a pdf file (i.e., an Adobe Acrobat Portable Document Format (.pdf), with the security settings set at “no security”) or similar electronic file corresponding to the Contribution as it appeared in the Publication. Following first publication of the Contribution in the Publication, in every instance in which the Author(s) or others authorized by the Author(s) republish the Contribution as it appeared in the Publication (whether as a .pdf or otherwise), or substantial portions thereof, or modified versions of the Contribution, the Author(s) agree to include attribution to the following effect:
“This article [or, if applicable: Portions of this article] first appeared in the [issue date] issue of [publication name] published by [publisher name]”, and to accurately distinguish any modified version of the Contribution from that published by UMP Publisher.”
- Warranties
The Author(s) warrants that:
- the Author(s) is the creator and author of the Contribution or otherwise have the rights necessary to grant the licenses granted to UMP Publisher herein; and
- the Contribution is original and contains no material that infringes or violates any intellectual property or contractual rights of others or that constitutes defamation or invasion of privacy.
The foregoing warranties apply only to the Contribution in the form submitted by the Author(s) to UMP Publisher, and not to any modifications or additions made by UMP Publisher, reviewers or other third parties.
- Termination
If UMP Publisher does not publish the Contribution in the Publication within twelve (12) months following submission of the Contribution, extended to the extent of any delays caused by the Author(s) if any, the Author(s) may terminate this agreement and the rights granted to UMP Publisher hereunder by providing UMP Publisher with written notice of termination of thirty (30) days, unless UMP Publisher guarantees that UMP Publisher shall publish the Contribution within three (3) months following receipt of such notice. Such termination of this agreement will be at the Author’s exclusive and sole remedy for any failure by UMP Publisher to publish the Contribution.
- Reservation of rights
Except for the express rights and licenses granted above, the Author(s) retains all rights, title, and interest in and to the Contribution.
- Miscellaneous
This agreement contains the entire understanding of the parties and will be governed by the laws of Malaysia. This agreement can only be modified by an agreement in writing signed by the parties. This agreement may be executed in one or more counterparts (including, without limitation, by facsimile or .pdf signature) each of which will be deemed an original and all of which will be taken together and deemed to be one instrument. UMP Publisher may assign this agreement in connection with a sale of the Publication or a sale, merger or reorganization of UMP Publisher.
